121 lines
4.7 KiB
TypeScript
Raw Normal View History

feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
/**
* Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation.
*
* Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the 'License");
* you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
* You may obtain a copy of the License at
*
* http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
*
* Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
* distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
* WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
* See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
* limitations under the License.
*/
import { blendWithWhite, colorDeltaE94, rgb2gray } from './colorUtils';
import { ImageChannel } from './imageChannel';
import { ssim, FastStats } from './stats';
const SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS = 15;
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
const VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS = 1;
function drawPixel(width: number, data: Buffer, x: number, y: number, r: number, g: number, b: number) {
const idx = (y * width + x) * 4;
data[idx + 0] = r;
data[idx + 1] = g;
data[idx + 2] = b;
data[idx + 3] = 255;
}
type CompareOptions = {
maxColorDeltaE94?: number;
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
};
export function compare(actual: Buffer, expected: Buffer, diff: Buffer|null, width: number, height: number, options: CompareOptions = {}) {
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
const {
maxColorDeltaE94 = 1.0,
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
} = options;
const paddingSize = Math.max(VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS, SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS);
const paddingColorEven = [255, 0, 255];
const paddingColorOdd = [0, 255, 0];
const [r1, g1, b1] = ImageChannel.intoRGB(width, height, expected, {
paddingSize,
paddingColorEven,
paddingColorOdd,
});
const [r2, g2, b2] = ImageChannel.intoRGB(width, height, actual, {
paddingSize,
paddingColorEven,
paddingColorOdd,
});
const noop = (x: number, y: number) => {};
const drawRedPixel = diff ? (x: number, y: number) => drawPixel(width, diff, x - paddingSize, y - paddingSize, 255, 0, 0) : noop;
const drawYellowPixel = diff ? (x: number, y: number) => drawPixel(width, diff, x - paddingSize, y - paddingSize, 255, 255, 0) : noop;
const drawGrayPixel = diff ? (x: number, y: number) => {
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
const gray = rgb2gray(r1.get(x, y), g1.get(x, y), b1.get(x, y));
const value = blendWithWhite(gray, 0.1);
drawPixel(width, diff, x - paddingSize, y - paddingSize, value, value, value);
} : noop;
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
let fastR, fastG, fastB;
let diffCount = 0;
for (let y = paddingSize; y < r1.height - paddingSize; ++y){
for (let x = paddingSize; x < r1.width - paddingSize; ++x) {
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
// Fast-path: equal pixels.
if (r1.get(x, y) === r2.get(x, y) && g1.get(x, y) === g2.get(x, y) && b1.get(x, y) === b2.get(x, y)) {
drawGrayPixel(x, y);
continue;
}
// Compare pixel colors using the dE94 color difference formulae.
// The dE94 is normalized so that the value of 1.0 is the "just-noticeable-difference".
// Color difference below 1.0 is not noticeable to a human eye, so we can disregard it.
// See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference
const delta = colorDeltaE94(
[r1.get(x, y), g1.get(x, y), b1.get(x, y)],
[r2.get(x, y), g2.get(x, y), b2.get(x, y)]
);
if (delta <= maxColorDeltaE94) {
drawGrayPixel(x, y);
continue;
}
if (!fastR || !fastG || !fastB) {
fastR = new FastStats(r1, r2);
fastG = new FastStats(g1, g2);
fastB = new FastStats(b1, b2);
}
const [varX1, varY1] = r1.boundXY(x - VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS, y - VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS);
const [varX2, varY2] = r1.boundXY(x + VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS, y + VARIANCE_WINDOW_RADIUS);
const var1 = fastR.varianceC1(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2) + fastG.varianceC1(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2) + fastB.varianceC1(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2);
const var2 = fastR.varianceC2(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2) + fastG.varianceC2(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2) + fastB.varianceC2(varX1, varY1, varX2, varY2);
// if this pixel is a part of a flood fill of a 3x3 square of either of the images, then it cannot be
// anti-aliasing pixel so it must be a pixel difference.
if (var1 === 0 || var2 === 0) {
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
drawRedPixel(x, y);
++diffCount;
continue;
}
const [ssimX1, ssimY1] = r1.boundXY(x - SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS, y - SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS);
const [ssimX2, ssimY2] = r1.boundXY(x + SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS, y + SSIM_WINDOW_RADIUS);
const ssimRGB = (ssim(fastR, ssimX1, ssimY1, ssimX2, ssimY2) + ssim(fastG, ssimX1, ssimY1, ssimX2, ssimY2) + ssim(fastB, ssimX1, ssimY1, ssimX2, ssimY2)) / 3.0;
const isAntialiased = ssimRGB >= 0.99;
if (isAntialiased) {
feat: implement a new image comparison function (#19166) This patch implements a new image comparison function, codenamed "ssim-cie94". The goal of the new comparison function is to cancel out browser non-determenistic rendering. To use the new comparison function: ```ts await expect(page).toHaveScreenshot({ comparator: 'ssim-cie94', }); ``` As of Nov 30, 2022, we identified the following sources of non-determenistic rendering for Chromium: - Anti-aliasing for certain shapes might be different due to the way skia rasterizes certain shapes. - Color blending might be different on `x86` and `aarch64` architectures. The new function employs a few heuristics to fight these differences. Consider two non-equal image pixels `(r1, g1, b1)` and `(r2, g2, b2)`: 1. If the [CIE94] metric is less then 1.0, then we consider these pixels **EQUAL**. (The value `1.0` is the [just-noticeable difference] for [CIE94].). Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If all the 8 neighbors of the first pixel match its color, or if the 8 neighbors of the second pixel match its color, then these pixels are **DIFFERENT**. (In case of anti-aliasing, some of the direct neighbors have to be blended up or down.) Otherwise, proceed to next step. 1. If SSIM in some locality around the different pixels is more than 0.99, then consider this pixels to be **EQUAL**. Otherwise, mark them as **DIFFERENT**. (Local SSIM for anti-aliased pixels turns out to be very close to 1.0). [CIE94]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_difference#CIE94 [just-noticeable difference]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-noticeable_difference
2022-12-02 15:22:05 -08:00
drawYellowPixel(x, y);
} else {
drawRedPixel(x, y);
++diffCount;
}
}
}
return diffCount;
}